I remember wanting to go to Liam's for the last two "event" dinners...and Mr. Flip Flop groaned about putting on "real clothes". We have REALLY gotten into the casual mode over our years at the coast! This year, I thought "heck, it's the island, wear what you want"! We sure aren't trying to impress anyone. LOL! If you have 'em, put on some blinged out flip flops and go on with your bad self. We saw folks in their work clothes, tropical shirts and shorts, dresses, slacks, etc. The island is well-known to be a "no tie zone" so no one should let the fact that they didn't bring any upscale clothes with them on vacation stop them from eating at one of the finest restaurants on the island.
The service was outstanding, the food was exceptionally delicious, and while a bit pricey, it was worth every dollar spent. A great addition to our list of places we will go for celebratory dinners.
We decided to skip alcohol since it was a week-night and his shift Friday was likely to be long and arduous. So, we splurged instead on an appetizer of Calamari - a beloved favorite. This dish was outstanding. Light textured crust and a generous plate of perfectly cooked nuggets of squid tentacles and rounds made us both smile!. Topping this dish with delicious slices of large green olives lightly dusted with Parmesan cheese was a surprising, yet scrumptious, addition to the plate. A crock of warm and spicy, chunky tomato dipping sauce was the perfect complement for the Calamari. Two huge thumbs up.
They also served a hot loaf of French bread with a scoop of soft butter. Delish! Best of all, the service was prompt and attentive, but never intrusive, The table setting was minimalist and lovely (you know I'm always checking out the dishes) with a crisp white tablecloth giving it the steakhouse vibe. The decor was definitely coastal, centered by a gorgeously appointed wooden bar with several people seated there sipping drinks. Quiet and "restrained" - which is a nice switch from some of the more hectic environments you sometimes find on a tourist concentric island.
Now, on to the rest of our dining experience. Mr. Flip Flop ordered the Prime Rib. It was served with asparagus and a loaded baked potato as well as a bowl of au jus. There was a small condiment bowl of creamy sauce, but I didn't even notice it until I was looking at the photo.
This angle gives a better idea of how thick and meaty this delicious prime rib actually was. He said everything was very good and he had to bring home part of the slab of meat as it was so big and thick. I'm sure it was the breakfast of champions before work this morning! The man loves eating leftovers for breakfast.
Now, I had heard the Cobb Salad was outstanding, so my decision was basically made before I arrived. The only thing I had to decide upon was my choice of beef filet, chicken, or shrimp as one of my toppings. It was a deliciously classic Cobb so my brain wanted to go with the chicken. However, those who raved about this salad had specifically raved about the Filet Cobb - so I went with that. I am so happy I did. It was too huge to finish but I did put a healthy dent in it. I also made sure to eat every bite of the tender, melt-in-your-mouth filet, the perfectly ripe avocado, the boiled eggs, and as much of the bacon and bleu cheese as I could. I was about to pop. I now know why my lady friends raved!
I will have to say I am glad it was a little dark in Liam's... I asked for my filet to be medium and that's a little more edging towards medium rare in my opinion. However, it was probably the better service for the meat - it literally melted in my mouth. Really glad I couldn't see it all that well at the time though!!!
Bottom line...go there. It was delightful and everything I could ask for (except a view) upon the occasion of my 22nd wedding anniversary! I give it my highest rating and will be back again soon! They are a small venue, so reservations are recommended during the busy times on the island. We fortunately didn't need them - but it wouldn't hurt if you want to avoid a potential wait! I didn't see a single soul hurrying through their dinner! Be safe, not sorry!
SPI FLIP FLOP FOODIE RATING:
5 – OMG – that was an outstanding meal! I can’t wait to go back